Rationalization
Chapter 21 · ~3.7k words

Seraphina was saved as 'Mom'. Not 'Aunt Phina'. Mom.
Elena stared at the letters on the screen until they blurred into black static. *Mom.* It was a biological fact she had already suspected, but seeing it spelled out in Bella’s casual shorthand—a contact entry between *Molly from Chem* and *Mr. Pizza*—made it nauseatingly real.
Bella wasn't a niece. She was a daughter. And Marcus wasn't a doting uncle. He was a father.
Elena handed the phone back to Bella, her fingers stiff.
"Thanks," Bella said, snatching the device without looking up. She was already texting again, her thumbs flying across the glass, sending messages to the woman who was slowly dismantling Elena's life.
Elena walked out of the sunroom. She needed to get away from the house, away from the lies that were embedded in the very drywall. But she couldn't leave yet. She had to maintain the charade until she had the lawyer's connection.
She went to the kitchen. It was neutral ground, a place of stainless steel and cold surfaces. She poured herself a glass of water, her reflection distorted in the chrome of the refrigerator.
Who was she in this house?
She looked at the family photos magneted to the fridge. There was Marcus and Seraphina at graduation. Marcus and Seraphina at Bella’s christening. Marcus and Seraphina on a ski trip.
And there, tucked in the corner, was one photo of Elena. It was from her wedding day. She was smiling, radiant, oblivious. Marcus had his arm around her, but his eyes weren't on her. He was looking at the camera. Or rather, at the person holding the camera.
Seraphina had taken that photo.
Elena peeled the picture off the fridge. She looked at herself. The hopeful, desperate woman in the white dress. She looked so young. So stupid.
She looked at her own face, searching for a family resemblance.
There was none. She had fair hair and blue eyes. The Hawthornes were all dark—black hair, olive skin, eyes like obsidian. Bella looked like Seraphina. Chloe looked like Seraphina. Even Marcus, with his slightly lighter hair, had the same bone structure.
They were a closed loop. A genetic fortress.
And she was the invasive species.
"Elena?"
She jumped. Chloe was standing in the doorway, holding a half-eaten apple.
"Are you okay?" the little girl asked.
"I'm fine, sweetie," Elena said, quickly sticking the photo back on the fridge. "Just... thirsty."
"You look sad," Chloe observed. "Like Mommy looks when Daddy leaves."
Elena froze. "When Daddy leaves?"
"Yeah. When he has to go back to the city. Mommy cries. She says it's not fair."
"Not fair that he has to work?" Elena asked gently.
Chloe took a bite of her apple. "No. Not fair that he has to come back to you."
The words were innocent, spoken without malice, but they hit Elena with the force of a physical blow.
"She says that?"
"Yeah. She says you're the... the placeholder." Chloe frowned, trying to remember the word. "Like in a book. You keep the spot until the real person comes back."
A placeholder. A toll booth. A wallet with legs.
"I see," Elena whispered.
"But I like you," Chloe added, sensing the tension. "You make good cookies."
"Thanks, Chloe."
"Are you really going to have a baby?" Chloe asked, pointing at Elena's stomach.
"We're trying."
Chloe scrunched up her nose. "I hope it looks like us. It would be weird if it looked like you."
"Why would it be weird?"
"Because," Chloe said, as if it were the most obvious thing in the world. "We're Hawthornes. Hawthornes look like Hawthornes."
She turned and skipped away, her ponytail bouncing.
Elena stood alone in the kitchen. She looked at her reflection in the fridge again. Chloe was right. She didn't belong here. She wasn't just an outsider; she was a biological distinct species in this house.